Self-Publishing Announcement

Contents

(Click on any line in the table of contents to be taken to that section.  Since this is going to be a long one, I’ve also split off some details into footnotes, marked like this: (1).  Click on them to be taken to the footnote section.)

  1. Summary
  2. The News
  3. The Backstory
  4. The Alternative
  5. Questions and Answers
  6. Footnotes

Summary

As of 2026, my US/Canada publisher, Penguin Random House, will no longer be publishing my Inheritance of Magic series since they want to publish fewer books by white authors.  As such, I’m going to be self-publishing the Inheritance of Magic series in North America from now on.  If you’re one of my US/Canada readers and you’d like to help, please buy a copy of the book.  If you’d like to know the full story, read on!

The News

In February 2026, I got an email from my agent telling me that she had bad news;  my US publisher, Penguin Random House, was not going to continue publishing my Inheritance of Magic series.

At the time, this blindsided me completely.  (It really shouldn’t have, due to the events of 5/6 years ago, but we’ll get to that later.)  When publishers drop a series, it’s usually because the series isn’t selling enough.  But in this case, I’d been under the impression that the sales of the Inheritance of Magic series were . . . fine?   

So I went and checked, and found more or less what I expected.  My Alex Verus books have consistently sold in the five-figure range in the US and Canada (generally in the low tens of thousands of copies), and looking at the numbers on the PRH website, the Inheritance of Magic series was looking more or less the same.  Looking at my last statement, Book #1 had been out for 20 months and had earned out its advance, Book #2 had been out for 7 months and was 98% of the way to earning out its advance, and while Book #3 hadn’t been out long enough to have a proper royalty statement yet, it was on course to do the same. (1)

Now, this might not mean much to those of you who’ve never had to deal with these sorts of payment models, so just for context:  books selling well enough to earn out their advance is actually really good!  Most books from big publishing houses do not earn out, and there are authors who go their entire careers without any of their books doing it even once.  So even though I’m not a big name, the fact that all of my books earn out makes me an unusually reliable seller as far as authors go.

But does being an unusually reliable seller mean actual profits for the publisher?  Well, translating sales into profits is difficult – advance sizes vary, and publishers are very tight-lipped about their profit margins.  However, if you ask around, industry insiders will pretty much all agree that the break-even point for an average book is going to be substantially less than the advance. (2)  If a book earns out, it’s probably well into the “profitable” category.  This means that all of my books were profitable for PRH – really profitable, in the case of the older Alex Verus books which by this point had earned out their advance many times over.

So I wrote to my contact at PRH asking why they were dropping me when my books were obviously making them money.  Her response was that:   

“. . . it was a business decision about the sales numbers and nothing to do with you as an author or the books themselves.  I know this is hard to understand . . . we have to also look at how the sales are trending.  The concern with “Inheritance of Magic” is that in spite of your strong reviews, bookstore accounts have not been supporting the print editions as we would have liked, and the sales of the series in other formats have been declining from book to book as well. When each book in a series is selling fewer copies than the last, it is not sustainable for us to continue publishing it.”

Now, at first glance, this explanation might sound plausible.  There’s only one problem:  it’s total bullshit.

The reality is that almost every book in a series sells fewer copies than the last, for the simple reason that most people who read a series start at the beginning.  This is obvious when you think about it:  not everyone who reads book 1 in a series will like it enough to read book 2, not everyone who reads book 2 will read book 3, and so on.  So with each book, a certain number of readers will fall away.  You can see this for yourself if you open up Goodreads or any similar site;  the number of entries for each book in a series slope downwards in a smooth curve.  The only exception is when one book in a series gets some sort of unusual boost (like a big award or something), but this is rare and even then the subsequent books will go right back to following the pattern.

This means that if publishers actually stopped publishing a series when each entry was selling fewer copies than the last, then pretty much no series would get finished, ever, and that goes for everything from the small niche ones all the way up to the giants like Lord of the Rings and Harry Potter.  But as long as the series as a whole is selling well, that doesn’t matter.  And, indeed, PRH US has published, and continues to publish, lots of series where each new book sells fewer copies than the last.

So what’s really going on?

Well, as a general rule, when you ask someone a question and they give you a nonsensical answer, it’s because the real answer is one they don’t want to tell you.  And in this case, there was a very obvious reason why PRH might not want to publish me, which is that PRH, and the American publishing industry in general, prefers to avoid publishing things written by white authors, particularly white males.

Now, you might wonder why I think this is the obvious reason.  To which the short answer is:  because they told me so.

The Backstory

Back when I signed on with Penguin Random House in 2010, they seemed quite happy to have me.  During the Alex Verus launch in 2012, they helped out with publicity and invited me along to author events.  The Alex Verus series duly became a success, and everything seemed to be going along happily . . . at first.

However, in the background, things were changing.  The New York publishing climate was becoming less and less focused on stories, and more and more focused on the identity of the authors who wrote them. (3) They didn’t want white male authors, they wanted ones who were “diverse”.  Now “diverse” in this context can refer to anything from sex to race to skin colour to sexuality to disability to several things more, but while people in the publishing world might differ over exactly what the word meant, one thing they could all agree on was that it didn’t include people like me. (4)

My first hint of what might be coming came during one of my rare visits to New York.  I met up with my contact at my publisher to talk about the Alex Verus series and the future, and as part of that I mentioned that I was thinking about what to write next, and I’d be interested to hear her take about what was currently popular and what her publisher was looking for.  (I don’t really write for the market, but I do try to pay some attention to it so that I have some idea about what is and isn’t likely to sell.)

The answer she gave me was that what they were really interested in right now was “own voices”, i.e. stories written by authors from groups that the publishers considered marginalised or under-represented. (5) Note that while I’d asked what kind of story they wanted, the answer I’d been given had been about what kind of author they wanted – specifically, which identity group the author fell into – and that kind of author wasn’t me.

Okay, so this wasn’t ideal.  I repeated the same conversation a couple of times over the next few years, hoping that I’d get a more helpful answer.  (I didn’t.)

Then in 2020, I got an email from PRH titled “Audit of PRH US Publishing Programs – Your Participation Is Requested”.  It contained a survey where they asked me to “indicate aspects of your demographic identity, including race and ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation, and disability”.  The stated purpose of this was to “increase the number of books we publish, promote, and sell by people of color” and it went on to explain that “as the world’s largest trade book publisher, we are committed to driving industry-wide change to make book publishing more inclusive, and we hope you’ll join us in our effort.” (6)

The email was followed up by multiple further emails urging me to complete the survey, subtitled “your help is crucial!”.  When I didn’t respond, my contact from PRH got in touch with me directly.  The conversation went as follows:

Them:  Dear Benedict, I am following up on a request for you to participate in our publishing program author survey.  By completing the survey, you will help provide us with an accurate picture of the demographic makeup of our authors and creatives, enabling us to set meaningful benchmarks as we work toward our goal of publishing more authors of color and providing books that reflect a diversity of experiences and viewpoints.
Me:  I appreciate you taking the time to email me, but when you say “we want to publish more authors of colour” and “we want to make book publishing more inclusive”, you do realise that you’re basically telling me “we want to publish fewer authors like you”?  The impression I’m getting from this survey is that your company is willing to publish my books, but would prefer it if I were a different person.
Them:  Not at all—I love working with you. I’m sorry you got this impression. The idea is to increase the overall inclusiveness of the authors we publish.
Me:  But you just said that your official corporate policy is to “publish more authors of colour”.  Which sort of implies publishing fewer authors like me.  You’re putting me in a really uncomfortable position here.
Them:  I am sorry you feel this way. I would never want you to do anything you weren’t comfortable with.

Looking back on it, the evasiveness of the conversation should probably have tipped me off as to what was coming, but it took a good five years for things to fully play out.  The Alex Verus series finished, and I planned and wrote the first book in the Inheritance of Magic series after that, but when I took it to PRH, they were notably less enthusiastic than they’d been ten years earlier.  They did agree to publish it – eventually – but they dragged their feet on the contracts, and when I asked for better payment terms than I’d been given for the previous books, they stonewalled me completely.

At the time, I found it frustrating.  Sure, huge multinational corporations are not known for their generosity, but by this point I was an established author who’d already made them a ton of money, so I’d thought that my publishers would be willing to treat me at least a little better.  Instead, they were treating me worse.  With hindsight, my mistake was assuming that money was their primary motive.  They obviously did care about it, but they cared about curating their list of authors more.  If I had to give my best guess at what they were thinking, it was probably something along the lines of “we’d prefer to replace this guy, but I guess we’ll give his new series a shot and if it’s REALLY profitable, we’ll keep him on”.  Once it became clear that the books were only going to be moderately profitable, they got rid of me. (7)

Which brings us up to 2026.  Over the next couple of months, on my agent’s urging, I tried approaching Little Brown, US (the American arm of my UK publisher) to see if they’d be willing to take over publishing the Inheritance of Magic series.  I wasn’t terribly enthusiastic – the big US publishing houses are mostly a monoculture these days and I had the feeling that I’d get the same sort of treatment that I’d had at PRH – so I was neither very upset nor very surprised when they said no (their excuse was that it was “too difficult to pick up a series at book 4”).

My agent’s recommendation was to try other publishers, but by this point the whole thing was starting to feel pretty futile.  As an author I’m used to rejection, but there’s a difference between a rejection that says ‘we don’t want this book’ and one that says ‘we don’t want you’.  One is worth going back to, the other isn’t.

Fortunately, there was an alternative.

The Alternative

Some of you may remember that back in 2021/2022, I put out a couple of Alex Verus short stories/novellas, which I ended up self-publishing on this website and on Amazon.  What I didn’t mention at the time was that part of the reason I was doing all that work that was that at the back of my mind, I’d had the thought that given some of the signals my publishers had been putting out, it might be a good idea to get familiar with how self-publishing worked.  Just in case.

Which is where we are now.  I’m going to be self-publishing the Inheritance of Magic series in the United States and Canada going forward.  Books #1-#3 in the series will continue to be published by PRH, but the ebook and audio editions of book #4, A Progression of Demons, will be self-published on Amazon.  (You can pre-order the ebook here;  the audio edition can’t be listed for pre-order yet, but should be published at the same time as the ebook.).  I’ll be keeping the same narrator for the audio editions, Will Watt. 

Release date will be March 23rd 2027, same as the UK.  My current plan is to self-publish books #5+ on Amazon in the same way.

So, what’s this going to mean for you?

Questions and Answers

Are you still going to finish the Inheritance of Magic series?

Yes.

Is this why Inheritance of Magic #4 is coming out 4 months late?

Partly.  My UK publisher had become used to having my US publisher doing part of the work.  When PRH dropped the series with no warning, they had to readjust to doing it all themselves.

I’m one of your UK/German/worldwide readers, how will this affect me?

Very little.  I still have publishing contracts with Orbit/Little Brown to publish the English version in the UK/worldwide, and with Verlag Random House to publish the German translation in Germany.  Print, ebook, and audio editions will release in your countries as normal.

I’m one of your US/Canada readers, how will this affect me?

If you read my books in ebook or audio format, you’ll now be buying them from me via Amazon, rather than from PRH.  (Realistically, most of my US/Canada readers will probably not even notice.)  The only difference is that a higher percentage of the sale price will now be going to me, rather than to my publisher (Amazon offers a 70% royalty rate for ebooks and 50% for audio, which is a better deal than traditional publishers offer).

The one major issue will be for those of you who buy the US paper edition.  I don’t currently have plans to put out a self-published paper copy of the US editions (only 10-15% of my US readers buy the paper copies, which makes it hard to justify cost-wise).  You can still get hold of the hardback/paperback UK editions, but you’ll have to import them, which’ll raise the price a bit.  Sorry.

How’s this going to affect the series in general?

So to answer this one, you have to look at what publishers offer authors.  From my point of view, the big things are editing, publicity, and distribution.

For editing, losing my US publisher won’t make much difference.  I already have a UK editor, and for the last few years the editorial advice I’ve been getting from my UK publisher has generally been more useful than what I’ve been getting from PRH, anyway.  It’ll mean fewer total eyes on the manuscript and a slightly shorter production timeline, but that’s unlikely to make a huge difference one way or the other.   

For publicity, it won’t make any difference at all.  The publicity/marketing/advertising I’ve been getting from PRH has been minimal for years now.  (This isn’t anything unusual – publishers usually do very little to advertise most of their authors.)

Distribution, though, will make a difference.  Probably the most important thing a publisher offers an author is reach – getting their books into bookstores and libraries, and listing them on lots of different online websites.  I don’t have the time or resources to do that, meaning that Books #4+ of the Inheritance of Magic series aren’t going to be as widely distributed in North America as books #1-#3 were.  I don’t know how many sales this will cost me, but I expect it’ll be a fair few.

On the plus side, I’ll be getting a bigger percentage of the sales that I do make (I don’t know whether this’ll add up to more or less money in the long run).  However, this’ll come at the cost of more admin;  instead of handing off the manuscript to my publisher and getting to work on the next one, from now on I’ll have to spend more time arranging the ebook, audio, formatting, etc of the US edition.  Hopefully this won’t slow down my release schedule, but I do think it’s likely that I’ll have less free time for things like worldbuilding articles.

Why haven’t you said anything about this before?

Because there was never much point.  This particular prejudice is widespread, normal, and accepted in the publishing industry.  The times I’ve spoken to people about it, the general advice I’ve gotten is to just put up with it because that’s just the way things are.

There’s also the fact that this kind of institutional discrimination is incredibly difficult to pin down.  Publishers will never admit that they’re getting rid of someone because they’re the wrong sex or skin colour or whatever – they’ll always come up with some excuse.  It’s the sales, it’s the trends, it’s the market, it’s the finances, etc etc.  And you can never find any one person who’ll take responsibility for it.  Even if I could somehow trace the person at PRH who made the decision to drop me, she’d say:  it’s not my fault, I’m just doing what my boss told me.  And if you went to her boss, her boss would say:  it’s not up to me, it’s company policy.  And if you try to blame the company, they’ll say:  it’s not our fault, we’re just following government guidance.  And so on.

Why are you saying something about this now?

Well, for one thing, I no longer have much to lose.  PRH have already dropped me;  what are they going to do, drop me again?

But the bigger reason is that at this point PRH have kind of backed me into a corner.  Their official line is that they’re discontinuing Inheritance of Magic because it isn’t selling;  if I keep quiet, everyone’s going to assume that’s true.  (And to be fair, that is the usual reason for a publisher to discontinue a series.)  But in this case I know that the series is selling just fine, because PRH’s own figures (from their own website!) say so.  So I feel like I have to speak up in its defence.

What are your feelings about the whole thing?

A bit depressed.  I’ve been with PRH for 13 years, and they were the ones who gave me my start in the US.  They didn’t do too much beyond that, but that start did make a difference, and for a long time I thought that I was welcome there.

Years passed, and things changed, and I gradually came to realise that I wasn’t so welcome after all.  But I had thought that I could at least count on PRH’s self-interest – so long as I was selling books and making them money, I thought they’d put up with the fact that I was the ‘wrong’ kind of author.  So having them effectively tell me “we not only don’t want you around, but we don’t want you around SO MUCH that we’re willing to give up somewhere between tens of thousands and hundreds of thousands of dollars just to get rid of you” is kind of dispiriting.

Still, I’ve survived worse.  And on the positive side, it’s often the case that when people push you out of a position where you’re not wanted, you often realise much later that they’ve (unintentionally) done you a favour.  If PRH hadn’t done this, I probably would have stayed with them for years and years.  As it is, I’m going to move into self-publishing in a bigger way.  We’ll see how it goes!

Anything else you’d like to say?

Just to say thanks to to all the readers who’ve supported the Alex Verus and Inheritance of Magic series so far!  You guys are the reason I’ve been able to keep doing this, so thank you.

At the moment I’m expecting the Inheritance of Magic series to run to maybe 10-12 books in total.  Book #4, A Progression of Demons, will be released on March 23rd 2027, and the (as-yet-untitled) Book #5 is finished as of November 2026, so I’m hoping to bring it out next year to follow on from Book #4.  Then there’ll be somewhere around 4-6 books after that, which I’m hoping to bring out on a similar release schedule, finishing around 2032 or so.

And that’s it!  Thanks for reading, and I’ll see you for the release of A Progression of Demons in March!

(Note:  Original version of this post went live Friday 20th November, 2026.  I’ll update it if things change.)

Footnotes

(1) ’Earning out’ means that the book’s royalty payments have met or exceeded the advance – if you want an explanation of what that means, you can find one here.  As of June 2026, this trend has continued;  Inheritance of Magic #1 and #2 have earned out, and Book #3, after 7 months of sales, is 96% of the way there.

(2) A very rough rule of thumb that I’ve heard bandied about is the 50% rule:  the breakeven point for a publisher is usually when the author gets somewhere around halfway to earning out their advance.  Anything beyond that is profit.

(3) The exact date of the tipping point is arguable.  Compact, which is one of the few magazines willing to touch the subject, has written a couple of good articles on it (“The Vanishing White Male Writer” and “The Lost Generation”) and they date it to around 2014. The way they put it is that if you were a white guy who made it before then, you had a chance of being “grandfathered in”, but from that point on, the pipeline pretty much dried up.  My Alex Verus series came out in 2012 and started to become properly successful around 2013-2015, which put me right on the borderline.

(4) I’m the son of an Australian father and an Armenian mother who both immigrated to London.  Although I’m quite happy with my heritage, it does mean that I’m just different enough that I don’t easily fit in here in England, but not visibly or obviously different enough to get any points from people who value that sort of thing.

(5) This is sort of like asking someone for financial advice, and being told “be born rich”.  Technically correct, but not all that helpful.

(6) For the sake of your sanity I’ve edited the email down.  The full thing is a page long (not including the survey itself) and it’s only one of dozens of similar emails that I’ve been sent over the years by PRH, all written in the same corporate-management-speak.

(7) I’m kind of spitballing here since I don’t have any realistic way to find out what really happened.  If anyone with more knowledge of this stuff (whether from PRH or anywhere else) ever reads this and feels like letting me know the actual story behind how the decision was made, send me an email.  It’s be nice to know, just for the sake of closure.